In this Discussion

Jim Derogatis

edited November -1 in OK Go
Jim Derogatis: "too clever and way too smarmy for their own good... annoying... gag-worthy..."

why did this review make the new letter? thats not very complimetary lol this confuses me

Comments

  • why not? i think putting a bad one in there to contrast the others gives the good ones more credibility.
  • I don't like him. He has a weird thing for the redwalls. My friends and I make fun of him. Yeah, that is also because we have nothing better to do. I like Greg Kot better. Okay, that's just chicago music writers I am talking about...Greg Kot=Tribune, Jim=Sun Times. I do not like the Sun Times.
  • To be fair Seifer he does have a point. Most people know i hate Ok Go with a passion so im going to tend to agree with negative comments regarding them, but their new album is laughably stolen from early material by The Game and there are clear signs of Abba in there too. Oh No was a fair title to the album
  • I was kind of glad that a bad review was in there. I didn't agree with most of the things that he said, but I could understand and see where he was coming from. It's good to have a few bad reviews mixed in with the good, if not for them OK Go would be built up so much.
  • QUOTE (Seifer @ Aug 30 2005, 05:35 PM)
    Jim Derogatis: "too clever and way too smarmy for their own good... annoying... gag-worthy..."

    why did this review make the new letter? thats not very complimetary lol this confuses me


    I thought it was pretty funny, and I bet the band/Mr. Mr. Jorge, Whom I Adore, Whom I Adore do, too. I mean, "gag-worthy"? That's impressive.
Sign In or Register to comment.